I own both of the Tartelette palettes and I have to say there BOTH so amazing, the only difference is that the first one is all matte and this one has 3 shimmer shades. Both palettes have amazing pigment and they blend like butter. One thing to point on is to be gentle with your brush on the shadows, because there is a lot of fall out. I love how this palette has all types of colours. From warm tones, reds/browns/gold’s in this palette (mix of everything). It’s a great variety of colours to create day or evening look. I honestly think this palette is worth its price cause you have everything you need to create a look, you can create a matte, neutral, shimmery or smokey eye just by using this palette. I love this baby! It has very pretty packaging, gorgeous colours, highly pigmented, blends effortlessly. If had to choose from the first one or this I would totally pick this one since it has a matte and shimmery shades.